ZIMBABWEAN homosexuals claiming asylum in the United Kingdom are more than likely to be turned down because the African country has a thriving “gay scene” and is “not the worst place in the world to be gay or lesbian”, a court ruled.
In a recent landmark judgement, the UK’s Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) left the door slightly ajar for asylum claimants whose personal circumstances place them at risk or suffer from HIV.
A Zimbabwean asylum seeker, known by the initials LZ, arrived in the United Kingdom in 1999. She claimed asylum in 2009, stating that she feared persecution as a lesbian back home.
The UK Home Office turned down her asylum bid leading to the case reaching the Upper Tribunal of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber.
In its judgment described as “significant” by immigration lawyers, the Upper Tribunal said it was “unable to accept that homosexuals are being persecuted as a generality when concrete examples are few, and when that standpoint is not supported by the best placed local observers”.
Finding that there has been much public expression of extreme homophobia at the highest levels in recent years, including by President Robert Mugabe and Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, Justices Macleman and Holmes went on: “Male homosexual behaviour is criminalised, but prosecutions are very rare. Lesbianism is not criminalised…
“There are no records of any murders with a homophobic element. ‘Corrective rape’ is rare, and does not represent a general risk.
“There is a ‘gay scene’ within limitations.”
The judges also noted that lesbians, living on their own or together, may face greater difficulties than gay men.
But the court was heavily swayed by a submission by the Gays and Lesbians Association of Zimbabwe (GALZ) which told a UK Border Agency fact finding mission that Zimbabwe is “not the worst place in the world to be gay or lesbian even though the President, government officials and church leaders have whipped up a climate of hysterical homophobia.”
Applying a standard set in an earlier ruling in HJ & HT, Judge Holmes and Judge Mclean said “there is no general risk to gays or lesbians” in Zimbabwe.
Full text of article available at link below –